evergreen · macro dissection ISM manufacturing and sector cycles

Manufacturing vs services — PMIs, inventories, and jobs

why manufacturing PMIs overshoot equities during inventory cycles — and how services resilience shaped the post-2020 expansion.

key definitions

PMI
purchasing managers' index — 50 is often the expansion/contraction line.
inventory cycle
businesses restock and destock amplifying short swings.
goods vs services
post-pandemic goods boom then mean reversion highlighted the wedge.

equity sectors rotate with the manufacturing pulse — semis, machinery, transports lead early cycle.

do not ignore services PMIs when judging labor market durability.

ISM manufacturing PMI — stylized annual avg
600019901999200820172026

early-1990s slump

1990 to 1992

manufacturing led the cleanup.

regime snapshot (contextual units — see chart label)
520-52381990471991521992
  • inventorydestock.
  • policyeasing.
lesson

industrials bottom before services employment.

PMI troughed under 50.

ISM

1995 to 2000 expansion

1995 to 2000

tech capex lifted manufacturing readings.

regime snapshot (contextual units — see chart label)
540-54481995541998422000
  • capexboom.
  • servicesstrong too.
lesson

late-cycle manufacturing heat can be policy bait.

PMI cyclically strong into 2000.

ISM

2001 recession and GFC

2001 to 2009

double manufacturing recession.

regime snapshot (contextual units — see chart label)
510-51432001512006382009
  • housing2000s cycle.
  • tradeglobal shock 2008.
lesson

manufacturing weakness + credit stress = avoid cyclicals.

PMI collapsed into 2009.

ISM

2010 to 2019 slow grind

2010 to 2019

manufacturing patchy; services carried jobs.

regime snapshot (contextual units — see chart label)
550-55552010522015482019
  • oil2015 shock.
  • dollar2013–2015 headwind.
lesson

flat manufacturing with calm credit can still lift broad indices via tech.

PMI oscillated near 50–60.

ISM

2020 to 2026 whipsaw

2020 to 2026

pandemic collapse, goods boom, normalization.

regime snapshot (contextual units — see chart label)
530-53432020532022482024502026
  • goodsspike then fade.
  • servicesreopening leader.
lesson

when goods mean-revert, do not confuse with full recession without services confirmation.

PMI crashed then rebounded before moderating.

ISM

refresh with actual ISM prints — stylized path illustrates typical recessions.

global manufacturing (China, EU) feeds US multinationals even with domestic services calm.

key takeaways

  • manufacturing is high beta to inventories.
  • services matter for payrolls.
  • global PMIs add context for exporters.
  • sector ETFs map cleanly to PMI phases.
  • one month ≠ regime.

faq

is PMI below 50 a recession?

not alone — depth and persistence matter, plus services.

China PMI vs US?

linked via supply chains; divergences happen.

why do stocks rally on bad PMI sometimes?

cuts pricing and mean reversion trades.

ISM vs S&P PMI?

different samples — watch methodology.

inventory restock playbooks?

early cyclicals and transports — timing is hard.

sources

  1. ISM: Manufacturing PMI
  2. FRED: NAPM
  3. Fed: Beige Book